Old Settlers Beach, Surf City NC Luxury Homes ($1M+) for Sale

This page lists the luxury homes ($1M+) for sale in Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC from Hive MLS listings, updated every few minutes, with the last 12 months of sales behind the prices — kept by the Buddy Blake Team.

As of November 6, 2026, there are 6 luxury homes ($1M+) for sale in Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC, with a middle asking price of $1,224,950 (from $1,049,000 to $1,780,000). 1 came on the market in the last week.

In the 12 months through November 6, 2026, 6 sold at a middle price of $1,200,000, typically for 100% of the first asking price after about 18 days on the market.

Newest luxury homes ($1M+) in Old Settlers Beach

$1,250,000

6 bd · 5 ba · 2,688 sq ft

0.15 ac · 2-car garage

0.2 mi from a public beach access

1019 1st Street, Surf City, NC 28445

Listed by Coldwell Banker Sea Coast Advantage

Price cut from $2.0M

$1,199,900

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,740 sq ft

0.18 ac · 3-car garage

0.6 mi from a public beach access

7097 7th Street, Surf City, NC 28445

Listed by SERHANT

$1,050,000

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,579 sq ft

0.18 ac · 1-car garage

0.5 mi from a public beach access

6075 6th Street, Surf City, NC 28445

Listed by eXp Realty

1919 N New River Drive, Surf City, NC 28445

Price cut from $1.79MNew · ready nowBuilder incentive mentioned

$1,780,000

5 bd · 5 ba · 3,200 sq ft

0.17 ac · 4-car garage

0.1 mi from a public beach access

1919 N New River Drive, Surf City, NC 28445

Listed by Keller Williams Innovate-Wilmington

Open Sat 9am–11amPrice cut from $1.06M

$1,049,000

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,440 sq ft

0.15 ac

0.2 mi from a public beach access

1023 1st Street, Surf City, NC 28445

Listed by REAL Broker LLC

$1,265,000

5 bd · 3 ba · 3,169 sq ft

0.15 ac · 1-car garage

0.1 mi from a public beach access

3011 3rd Street, Surf City, NC 28445

Listed by Coldwell Banker Sea Coast Advantage-Leland

Search every home with filters and a map →

Asking prices in Old Settlers Beach

Under $300K0
$300K–$500K0
$500K–$750K0
$750K–$1M0
$1M+6

Questions about luxury homes ($1M+) in Old Settlers Beach, answered

How many luxury homes ($1M+) are for sale in Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC?

What do luxury homes ($1M+) cost in Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC?

As of November 6, 2026, the middle asking price is $1,224,950, about $611 per square foot for a typical 2,214 sq ft. $1M+: 6.

What did luxury homes ($1M+) sell for in Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC last year?

In the 12 months through November 6, 2026, 6 sold at a middle price of $1,200,000, typically for 100% of the first asking price after about 18 days on the market.

How fast do luxury homes ($1M+) sell in Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC?

In the 12 months through November 6, 2026 they typically sold in about 18 days, at 100% of the first asking price.

How do I estimate a monthly payment on a home in Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC?

A mortgage payment has two parts: principal and interest, which depend on the price, your down payment and the rate a lender offers you; and the costs on top — property taxes, homeowners insurance (and flood insurance near the water), HOA dues where there's an association, and mortgage insurance if you put less than 20% down. Each home's page has a calculator that uses the rate you've been quoted and that home's own taxes and HOA dues from the listing. For your actual rate and Annual Percentage Rate (APR), ask a licensed lender — we can introduce you to Joey Milam at Alpha Mortgage Advantage, or you're free to choose any lender.

Explore more

Luxury ($1M+) across all 5 counties About Old Settlers Beach: stats, sales & map Luxury ($1M+) in all of Surf City Luxury ($1M+) in Onslow County Single-family One-story Primary on main Open houses New this week Price reduced

Figures are computed live from MLS listing data for Old Settlers Beach in Surf City, NC, luxury ($1m+) only. Middle = median. Listing data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.