Homes for sale in Old Settlers Beach
17 homes · newest first
Who sells the most in Old Settlers Beach?
Counted from every closed Hive MLS sale here, 2022–2026: Coldwell Banker Sea Coast has closed more sales in Old Settlers Beach than any other company — 56 to Intracoastal Realty's 30. When you sell here, that's the most buyers' agents and the most local sales knowledge working for you.
Top six companies, 2022–2026
Year by year
Coldwell Banker Sea CoastNext-biggest company that year
Every bar opens the actual sales behind it. Each sale has two sides (listing and buyer), credited to the company on each side. * 2026 is the year to date. See how it compares across Southeastern NC →
About Old Settlers Beach
Old Settlers Beach is a residential community in Surf City, in Pender County, North Carolina. Its homes were built between 1940 and 9999. A typical home here is about 1,586 square feet with 3 bedrooms.
In the 12 months through November 5, 2026, 19 homes sold in Old Settlers Beach at a middle price of $838,500 (about $505 per square foot). Sellers typically received 95.5% of their first asking price, after about 22 days on the market.
Old Settlers Beach has single-family homes, manufactured homes and townhomes. Over the last year, single-family homes sold at a middle price of $870,000, while manufactured homes sold at a middle price of $490,000, while townhomes sold at a middle price of $475,000.
Community features named in Old Settlers Beach's listings: Boating access and Waterfront homes. Check current details and dues with the HOA.
The closest elementary school is Surf City Elementary School (3.5 mi), the nearest grocery store is Surf City IGA (2.1 mi), the nearest public beach access is 0.3 miles away.
Streets in Old Settlers Beach
13 streets · A–ZTap a street to see its homes. Every address comes from county property records where we have them; homes for sale and sold in the last 12 months come from the MLS.
By type of home
Old Settlers Beach has more than one kind of home, and they price differently. Sales are the last 12 months.
Single-family homes
- For sale now
- 15
- Middle asking price
- $965,000
- Sold, last 12 mo
- 14
- Middle sale price
- $870,000
- Per square foot
- $498
- Typical size
- 1,636 sq ft
- Of first asking price
- 97.9%
- Days on market
- 15
Manufactured homes
- For sale now
- 2
- Middle asking price
- $782,000
- Sold, last 12 mo
- 4
- Middle sale price
- $490,000
- Per square foot
- $545
- Typical size
- 1,248 sq ft
- Of first asking price
- 94.4%
- Days on market
- 94
Townhomes
- For sale now
- 0
- Middle asking price
- —
- Sold, last 12 mo
- 1
- Middle sale price
- $475,000
- Per square foot
- $521
- Typical size
- 1,366 sq ft
- Of first asking price
- 95%
- Days on market
- 55
Sold in Old Settlers Beach, last 6 months
Newest first · from MLS records- Sales
- 14
- Middle sale price
- $839,250
- Price range
- $490,000 – $2,152,000
- Middle $ / sq ft
- $531
- Of first asking price
- 97.9%
- Middle days on market
- 19
- 4069 4th Street, Surf City$840,000
Sold Oct 15, 26 · 5 bd / 4 ba · 2,336 sq ft · 97.1% of first asking · 421 days on market
Listed by Intracoastal Realty Corporation - 922 Broadway Street, Surf City$1,150,000
Sold Sep 30, 26 · 4 bd / 3 ba · 2,347 sq ft · 100.0% of first asking · 3 days on market
Listed by Landmark Sotheby's International Realty - 9091 W 9th Street, Surf City$1,775,000
Sold Aug 21, 26 · 4 bd / 5 ba · 3,678 sq ft · 98.6% of first asking · 22 days on market
Listed by Carolina One Properties Inc. Sold Aug 18, 26 · 4 bd / 2 ba · 1,598 sq ft · 94.8% of first asking · 16 days on market
Listed by 910 Realty Co.- 3031 3rd Street, Surf City$635,000
Sold Aug 14, 26 · 2 bd / 1 ba · 884 sq ft · 94.1% of first asking · 8 days on market
Listed by Live Where You Love Realty LLC Sold Jul 30, 26 · 2 bd / 2 ba · 768 sq ft · 100.0% of first asking · 4 days on market
Listed by Rebarker Real Estate, LLC- 4059 4th Street, Surf City$1,200,000
Sold Jul 23, 26 · 4 bd / 3 ba · 1,632 sq ft · 100.0% of first asking · 9 days on market
Listed by Northside Realty, Inc. - 9059 W 9th Street, Surf City$2,152,000
Sold Jun 22, 26 · 4 bd / 4 ba · 3,475 sq ft · 100.1% of first asking · 49 days on market
Listed by Coldwell Banker Sea Coast Advantage - 4090 4th Street, Surf City$850,000
Sold Jun 16, 26 · 4 bd / 2 ba · 1,809 sq ft · 100.0% of first asking · 10 days on market
Listed by Coastal Carolina Real Estate - 6015 6th Street, Surf City$490,000
Sold Jun 16, 26 · 3 bd / 2 ba · 790 sq ft · 78.4% of first asking · 147 days on market
Listed by Coastal Realty Associates LLC - 4058 4th Street, Surf City$490,000
Sold Jun 9, 26 · 2 bd / 1 ba · 619 sq ft · 93.3% of first asking · 40 days on market
Listed by Teresa Batts Real Estate, LLC - 3083 3rd Street, Surf City$1,200,000
Sold May 26, 26 · 3 bd / 2 ba · 2,520 sq ft · 100.0% of first asking · 14 days on market
Listed by Century 21 Coastal Advantage Sold May 15, 26 · 3 bd / 3 ba · 1,282 sq ft · 89.9% of first asking · 144 days on market
Listed by Keller Williams Innovate-Wilmington- 6114 6th Street, Surf City$838,500
Sold May 14, 26 · 3 bd / 2 ba · 1,660 sq ft · 90.6% of first asking · 37 days on market
Listed by RE/MAX Southern Coast
| Address | Sold | Bd / Ba | Sq ft | First asking | Last asking | Sold price | % of first asking | $ / sq ft | Days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4069 4th Street, Surf City
| Oct 15, 26 | 5 / 4 | 2,336 | $865,000 | $865,000 | $840,000 | 97.1% | $360 | 421 |
| 922 Broadway Street, Surf City
| Sep 30, 26 | 4 / 3 | 2,347 | $1,150,000 | $1,150,000 | $1,150,000 | 100.0% | $490 | 3 |
| 9091 W 9th Street, Surf City
| Aug 21, 26 | 4 / 5 | 3,678 | $1,800,000 | $1,800,000 | $1,775,000 | 98.6% | $483 | 22 |
| 2016 N New River Drive, Surf City
| Aug 18, 26 | 4 / 2 | 1,598 | $675,000 | $675,000 | $640,000 | 94.8% | $401 | 16 |
| 3031 3rd Street, Surf City
| Aug 14, 26 | 2 / 1 | 884 | $675,000 | $675,000 | $635,000 | 94.1% | $718 | 8 |
| 1906 N New River Drive, Surf City
| Jul 30, 26 | 2 / 2 | 768 | $549,900 | $549,900 | $549,900 | 100.0% | $716 | 4 |
| 4059 4th Street, Surf City
| Jul 23, 26 | 4 / 3 | 1,632 | $1,200,000 | $1,200,000 | $1,200,000 | 100.0% | $735 | 9 |
| 9059 W 9th Street, Surf City
| Jun 22, 26 | 4 / 4 | 3,475 | $2,150,000 | $2,150,000 | $2,152,000 | 100.1% | $619 | 49 |
| 4090 4th Street, Surf City
| Jun 16, 26 | 4 / 2 | 1,809 | $850,000 | $850,000 | $850,000 | 100.0% | $470 | 10 |
| 6015 6th Street, Surf City
| Jun 16, 26 | 3 / 2 | 790 | $624,900 | $539,000 | $490,000 | 78.4% | $620 | 147 |
| 4058 4th Street, Surf City
| Jun 9, 26 | 2 / 1 | 619 | $525,000 | $525,000 | $490,000 | 93.3% | $792 | 40 |
| 3083 3rd Street, Surf City
| May 26, 26 | 3 / 2 | 2,520 | $1,200,000 | $1,200,000 | $1,200,000 | 100.0% | $476 | 14 |
| 2010 N New River Drive, Surf City
| May 15, 26 | 3 / 3 | 1,282 | $795,000 | $750,000 | $715,000 | 89.9% | $558 | 144 |
| 6114 6th Street, Surf City
| May 14, 26 | 3 / 2 | 1,660 | $925,000 | $925,000 | $838,500 | 90.6% | $505 | 37 |
| Average | 1,814 | $998,914 | $989,564 | $966,100 | 95.5% | $567 | 66 |
First asking = the price when the home first listed; days on market counts every listing period for the home. Sold data from Hive MLS; deemed reliable, not guaranteed.
Own a home in Old Settlers Beach?
Get an email when homes here sell, with what they sold for.
What's my home worth in Old Settlers Beach?
In the last 6 months, 14 homes sold in Old Settlers Beach for $490,000 to $2,152,000, a middle of about $531 per square foot. Here's how that breaks down — and a quick way to see where your home might fall.
| Bedrooms | Sales | Middle sale price | Range | Middle $ / sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 bedrooms | 3 | $549,900 | $490K – $635K | $718 |
| 3 bedrooms | 4 | $776,750 | $490K – $1.2M | $531 |
| 4 bedrooms | 6 | $1,175,000 | $640K – $2.15M | $486 |
Type your size to see the range homes like yours sold for. Nothing you type is sent or saved.
Get my home's value →A home value report built from the sales above and the homes for sale around you.
Sale prices over time
Middle sale price each quarter, last three years. Quarters with fewer than two sales are left out.
What's nearby
Schools
- Surf City Elementary SchoolElementary school · 3.5 mi
- Surf City Middle SchoolMiddle school · 3.4 mi
- Dixon High SchoolHigh school · 9.8 mi
Everyday
- Surf City IGAGrocery · 2.1 mi · ★ 4.5
- Walmart Neighborhood MarketGrocery · 2.7 mi · ★ 4.1
- Sundial Coffee and TeaCoffee · 2.5 mi · ★ 4.9
- Surf City CoffeeCoffee · 2.1 mi · ★ 4.8
- Shaka Taco Surf CityDining · 2 mi · ★ 4.7
- Topsail Steamer SeafoodDining · 2.3 mi · ★ 4.7
- Daybreak DonutsDining · 2.3 mi · ★ 4.7
- Our Yard Your SaleShopping · 4 mi · ★ 4.5
Outdoors
- Broadway Beach access parkingBeach · 0.3 mi · ★ 4
- Public Beach Access #7Beach · 0.6 mi · ★ 4.9
- Public Boat RampBoating · 2.2 mi · ★ 4.4
- Turkey Creek Boat Access AreaBoating · 4.5 mi · ★ 4.6
- Nelva R. Albury Recreation AreaPark · 0.3 mi · ★ 4.6
- Soundside ParkPark · 2.1 mi · ★ 4.8
- Shipwreck Point GolfGolf · 2.5 mi · ★ 4.1
Health
- Sandy Shores Medical Center & Urgent CareHospital · 2.5 mi · ★ 4.3
Distances are straight-line from the middle of Old Settlers Beach. Schools shown are the closest, not necessarily assigned — confirm with the district. Place details © Google.
Old Settlers Beach questions, answered
How many homes are for sale in Old Settlers Beach?
17 homes are for sale in Old Settlers Beach right now, with a middle asking price of $959,000 (from $575,000 to $1,780,000).
What do homes in Old Settlers Beach sell for?
In the 12 months through November 5, 2026 the middle sale price in Old Settlers Beach was $838,500, about $505 per square foot, across 19 sales. Every home differs — size, condition and lot matter.
What's my home worth in Old Settlers Beach?
Homes in Old Settlers Beach sold for a middle of about $531 per square foot over the last 6 months (14 sales), so a 2,000 sq ft home would be roughly $1,063,000 before condition, updates, lot and view. For your home's own number, use the home value tool — it lines up every online estimate next to these sales.
Are there townhomes or condos in Old Settlers Beach?
Old Settlers Beach has single-family homes (15 for sale now, middle sale price $870,000 over the last year); manufactured homes (2 for sale now, middle sale price $490,000 over the last year); townhomes (0 for sale now, middle sale price $475,000 over the last year).
How fast do homes sell in Old Settlers Beach?
Homes that sold in Old Settlers Beach over the last year were typically on the market about 22 days and sold for 95.5% of their first asking price.
What schools are near Old Settlers Beach?
Surf City Elementary School (3.5 mi), Surf City Middle School (3.4 mi), Dixon High School (9.8 mi). These are the closest schools, not necessarily the assigned ones — confirm assignment with the school district for a specific address.
How far is Old Settlers Beach from the beach?
The nearest public beach access, Broadway Beach access parking, is about 0.3 miles away in a straight line.
What amenities does Old Settlers Beach have?
Homes listed for sale in Old Settlers Beach describe these community features: Boating access and Waterfront homes. Amenities, dues and memberships can change — confirm the details with the homeowners association.
Own a home in Old Settlers Beach?
Get a home value report built from real sales in Old Settlers Beach — not an online guess.
How homes really sell in Surf City
How many listings sold and how many didn't, how long they took, what they sold for against the first price, and how often contracts fell apart — the last 12 months, with a printable PDF.
From Buddy's blog: Surf City area
- How New Wilmington NC Employers Drive Relocation DemandJul 31, 2026
- Capital Gains Tax Exclusion on Home Sales Could Double: What Wilmington, NC Homeowners Need to KnowJul 12, 2026
- What Zillow and Realtor.com Aren't Telling You — And How It Could Cost Heroes Their BenefitsJun 29, 2026
- A Memorial Day Morning at Chick-fil-A in Porter's Neck: Honoring Those Who Gave EverythingMay 22, 2026
More communities in Surf City
- Del Mar Beach · 8 for sale
- Waterside · 7 for sale
- Surf City # · 7 for sale
- Dune Ridge · 7 for sale
- Topsail Cove · 5 for sale
- Beach House Yacht Club · 5 for sale
- Sandy Ridge · 3 for sale
- Sea Star Village · 3 for sale
- Egret Landing · 3 for sale
- Sears Landing · 3 for sale
- J H Batts · 3 for sale
- Island Oaks · 2 for sale