$575,000

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,786 sq ft

420 Sheldon Road Southern Pines, NC 28387 · The Cottages on May

Status checked with the MLS Nov 16, 1:04 AM

Market checkSimilar homes in Southern Pines near this price sold for a median 99% of first asking price in 25 days (70 sales, last 6 months) See recent sales ↓

Hive MLSListed by Coldwell Banker Advantage-Southern Pines

Track this home: get an email if its price drops or it goes under contract.

Email me if this home's price drops or it goes under contract, plus new listings like it. Stop anytime.

Thinking of selling yours first? See what it's worth →

Video tour

About this home

Picture yourself taking your first sip of coffee on the upstairs porch as morning light settles over the horse pastures across the street. That view makes coming home feel special. With classic Southern architecture, a welcoming covered front porch and a second-story porch overlooking the neighboring horse farm, this charming two-story home makes the most of its setting. Mature trees and beautiful landscaping make the street a lovely place for an evening stroll or a bike ride. Inside, the open floor plan brings everyone together around a generous kitchen island. The gourmet kitchen features a natural gas range and opens to a cozy living room with a gas fireplace. The main-level primary suite, currently used as a home office, offers a large walk-in closet and a modern bath with a tiled walk-in shower. A whole-house tankless natural gas water heater adds everyday convenience. Upstairs, two bedrooms share a Jack-and-Jill bath, and a den or loft offers room to read, unwind or work. Step onto the upper porch to take in the sweeping pasture views. Out back, a spacious covered porch and large patio make it easy to host a cookout, linger over dinner with friends or enjoy a quiet evening outdoors. The fenced backyard also features a storage shed for yard equipment, and the detached garage offers additional space. Just minutes from downtown Southern Pines, you can meet friends for coffee, browse local boutiques, try a neighborhood restaurant or brewery, and enjoy parks and community events. Golf courses, schools, grocery stores and healthcare are also nearby. Come see the home, then take a moment on the upper porch to imagine ending your day with a favorite drink and that peaceful view across the pastures. The $175 per month HOA covers all landscaping maintenance for the home/neighborhood, the private road access behind the home, as well as the neighborhood amenities of the clubhouse & pool.

Facts

Type
Single Family Residence
Year built
2019
Lot
0.26 acres
Garage
1 space
HOA
$2,340 / annually
Community
The Cottages on May
County
Moore
Price per sq ft
$322
Stories
2
Construction
Fiber Cement, Wood Frame
Roof
Composition
Foundation
Crawl Space
Water
Public
Property tax
$3,035 / year (2026)
Listed
Nov 6, 2026
MLS #
100614882

Features

Inside

  • Master Downstairs
  • Walk-in Closet(s)
  • Bookcases
  • Kitchen Island
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Pantry
  • Walk-in Shower
  • Blinds/Shades
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • Gas Log
  • Smart Thermostat
  • Walk-In Closet(s)
  • LVT/LVP
  • Tile
  • Gas Oven
  • Built-In Microwave

Outside

  • Irrigation System
  • Interior Lot
  • Level
  • Recreation Nearby
  • Rectangular Lot
  • Shopping Nearby
  • None

Community

  • Clubhouse
  • Community Pool
  • Maintenance Common Areas
  • Maintenance Grounds
  • Meeting Room
  • Party Room
  • Playground
  • Sidewalks
  • Street Lights
  • Recreation Nearby

Parking

  • Garage Faces Rear
  • Detached
  • Gravel
  • Garage Door Opener
  • Off Street
  • Garage

Heating & cooling

  • Heat Pump
  • Fireplace(s)
  • Electric
  • Central Air
  • Ceiling Fan(s)

Directions to 420 Sheldon Road

May Street to E Delaware Ave, bare left onto Youngs Rd, 2nd left onto Sheldon Rd, OR May Street to Springwood Way, past clubhouse & community pool, left onto Petty St, Rt onto Duncan Rd, Right onto Sheldon Rd

Schools

Elementary
McDeeds Creek Elementary
Middle
Crain's Creek Middle
High
Pinecrest High

As listed in the MLS (Moore County Schools). School assignments can change — confirm with the district for this address.

Payment calculator

Enter the rate a lender quoted you and pick a down payment to see principal and interest for this home. Not sure what to use? See this week's national average at Freddie Mac ↗

Get your actual rate for this home — usually same day

📱 Text Joey

Joey Milam, Alpha Mortgage Advantage · NMLS #117399 · You're free to choose any lender.

Recent sales like this nearby

HomeSoldBd / BaSq ftPrice$ / sq ft
272 Springwood Way, Southern PinesFeb 27, 20263 / 21,359$441,000$325
1335 N Ridge Street, Southern PinesMay 29, 20263 / 21,743$217,000$124
745 N May Street, Southern PinesJul 22, 20263 / 21,341$567,000$423
760 N May Street, Southern PinesJun 30, 20263 / 21,462$499,000$341

Similar size and type, sold in the last 6 months. From Hive MLS records; deemed reliable, not guaranteed.

Own a home in Southern Pines?

Get an email when homes here sell, with what they sold for — and see what yours is worth.

What's my home worth? →

Buying in Southern Pines? Local guides

Explore the area

About 420 Sheldon Road

420 Sheldon Road is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath home of about 1,786 square feet, built in 2019, on 0.26 acres in The Cottages on May, Southern Pines, Moore County, NC 28387.

3 other homes are for sale in The Cottages on May right now (median asking $524,900); 1 home sold there in the last 12 months for $441,000.

Across ZIP 28387, 147 3-bedroom homes sold in the past year at a median of $420,000.

Area figures are broad context from the MLS, not a valuation — they don't adjust for condition, lot, views or updates. Ask us for a true comparison.

Buying 420 Sheldon Road

  1. See it in person. Pick a time and we'll call to confirm — often same day.
  2. See the cost of waiting. What waiting could cost you on this home, and what it could look like 10 years from now, using today's national rate and 20 years of home price history.
  3. Have a home to sell first? Our guaranteed sale lets you buy with a firm plan for your current home. How it works

Own a home near 420 Sheldon Road? See what it's worth — a home value report built from real sales in The Cottages on May.

What's my home worth? →

Questions about 420 Sheldon Road

How much is 420 Sheldon Road?

420 Sheldon Road is under contract. Its last asking price was $575,000.

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 420 Sheldon Road have?

3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, with about 1,786 square feet.

What neighborhood is 420 Sheldon Road in?

The Cottages on May, in Southern Pines, Moore County, North Carolina.

What have homes sold for in The Cottages on May?

Only 1 home sold in The Cottages on May in the last 12 months for $441,000 — too few for a reliable typical price.

Does 420 Sheldon Road have an HOA fee?

Yes: $2,340 (annually), per the MLS.

When was 420 Sheldon Road built?

2019.

Who is the listing broker for 420 Sheldon Road?

Coldwell Banker Advantage-Southern Pines (MLS #100614882).

Can I tour 420 Sheldon Road?

Yes. Tap “Schedule a tour,” pick a time, and we'll call to confirm — or call or text (910) 395-1000.

Listing provided by Coldwell Banker Advantage-Southern Pines via Hive MLS.