Homes under $500K for sale in Castalia, NC

As of October 19, 2026, there are 14 homes under $500K for sale in Castalia, NC, with a middle asking price of $280,999 (from $174,000 to $340,640). 1 came on the market in the last week. Another 7 are under contract.

In the 12 months through October 19, 2026, 18 sold at a middle price of $248,444, typically for 94.3% of the first asking price after about 96 days on the market.

The most choices right now are in Harrison & Main, Culpepper Landing.

Newest homes under $500K in Castalia

10875 Lancaster Store Road, Castalia, NC 27816

New · ready now

$285,888

4 bd · 3 ba · 2,014 sq ft

0.69 ac · 2-car garage

10875 Lancaster Store Road, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by WJH Brokerage NC LLC

$174,000

3 bd · 2 ba · 875 sq ft

0.46 ac

9349 Main Street, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by United Real Estate Tri-County

9357 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

New · ready ~Nov 7Builder incentive mentioned

$286,999

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,536 sq ft

0.78 ac · 4-car garage

9357 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Keller Williams Central

9341 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

New · ready ~Nov 7Builder incentive mentioned

$290,999

3 bd · 3 ba · 1,599 sq ft

0.71 ac · 2-car garage

9341 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Keller Williams Central

9301 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

New · ready ~Nov 7Builder incentive mentioned

$278,999

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,494 sq ft

0.70 ac · 2-car garage

9301 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Keller Williams Central

New · ready now

$239,900

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,504 sq ft

0.98 ac

7521 Alice Court, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by United Country Respess Real Estate

Open Sat 1pm–4pmNew · ready now

$309,900

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,721 sq ft

0.71 ac · 2-car garage · $50/mo HOA

7149 Luke Lane, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Dream Finders Realty LLC

Open Sat 1pm–4pmNew · ready now

$340,640

4 bd · 3 ba · 2,267 sq ft

0.61 ac · 2-car garage · $50/mo HOA

7117 Luke Lane, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Dream Finders Realty LLC

Open Sat 1pm–4pmNew · ready now

$286,965

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,504 sq ft

0.56 ac · 2-car garage · $50/mo HOA

7061 Luke Lane, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Dream Finders Realty LLC

9325 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

New · ready nowBuilder incentive mentioned

$282,999

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,527 sq ft

0.72 ac · 2-car garage

9325 Harrison Street, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Keller Williams Central

Price cut from $262KNew · ready nowBuilder incentive mentioned

$247,997

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,608 sq ft

0.98 ac · 2-car garage

11365 Red Bud Road, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Key Realty Solutions

Price cut from $264KNew · ready nowBuilder incentive mentioned

$249,997

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,608 sq ft

1.1 ac · 2-car garage

11455 Red Bud Road, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Key Realty Solutions

Price cut from $258KNew · ready nowBuilder incentive mentioned

$239,997

4 bd · 3 ba · 1,508 sq ft

1 ac · 2-car garage

11441 Red Bud Road, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by Key Realty Solutions

New · ready now

$274,900

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,716 sq ft

1.4 ac

7600 Alice Court, Castalia, NC 27816

Listed by United Country Respess Real Estate

Search every home with filters and a map →

Price mix

Under $300K12
$300K–$500K2
$500K–$750K0
$750K–$1M0
$1M+0

Where they are

Harrison & Main · Castalia · 3 for sale · $286,999 middle
Culpepper Landing · Castalia · 2 for sale · $257,400 middle

Under $500K in nearby towns

Rocky Mount261 for sale Nashville39 for sale Bailey38 for sale Spring Hope31 for sale Battleboro16 for sale Whitakers12 for sale

Questions, answered

How many homes under $500K are for sale in Castalia, NC?

What do homes under $500K cost in Castalia, NC?

As of October 19, 2026, the middle asking price is $280,999, about $170 per square foot for a typical 1,568 sq ft. Under $300K: 12; $300K–$500K: 2.

What did homes under $500K sell for in Castalia, NC last year?

In the 12 months through October 19, 2026, 18 sold at a middle price of $248,444, typically for 94.3% of the first asking price after about 96 days on the market.

How fast do homes under $500K sell in Castalia, NC?

In the 12 months through October 19, 2026 they typically sold in about 96 days, at 94.3% of the first asking price.

Which communities in Castalia, NC have the most homes under $500K for sale?

As of October 19, 2026, Harrison & Main (3), Culpepper Landing (2).

How do I estimate a monthly payment on a home in Castalia, NC?

A mortgage payment has two parts: principal and interest, which depend on the price, your down payment and the rate a lender offers you; and the costs on top — property taxes, homeowners insurance (and flood insurance near the water), HOA dues where there's an association, and mortgage insurance if you put less than 20% down. Each home's page has a calculator that uses the rate you've been quoted and that home's own taxes and HOA dues from the listing. For your actual rate and Annual Percentage Rate (APR), ask a licensed lender — we can introduce you to Joey Milam at Alpha Mortgage Advantage, or you're free to choose any lender.

Explore more

Under $500K across all 5 counties Under $500K in Nash County Communities in Castalia Single-family One-story Primary on main Open houses New this week Price reduced

Figures are computed live from MLS listing data for Castalia, NC, under $500k only. Middle = median. Listing data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.