Pleasure Cay homes for sale

Carolina Beach · New Hanover County, North Carolina

  • Boating access
  • Water access
  • Waterfront homes
Stop anytime.Own here? See what it's worth →

0

For sale now

1 under contract

—

Middle asking price

$1,240,000

Middle sale price

1 sales, last 12 mo

$590

Per square foot

sold, last 12 mo

100.6%

Of first asking price

what sellers received

17

Days on market

typical, last 12 mo

Homes for sale in Pleasure Cay

Nothing for sale here right now. Get an alert and we'll tell you the moment one lists.

Under contract in Pleasure Cay

1 pending
502 Peninsula Drive, Carolina Beach, NC 28428Under contract

$649,900

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,747 sq ft

0.28 ac · 1-car garage · $27/mo HOA

0.7 mi from a public beach access

502 Peninsula Drive, Carolina Beach, NC 28428

Hive MLSListed by Nest Realty

About Pleasure Cay

Watercolor map of Pleasure Cay in Carolina Beach, NC, showing its streets, water and surroundings
Watercolor map of Pleasure Cay in Carolina Beach, NCMap by Buddy Blake Team · Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors

Pleasure Cay is a residential community in Carolina Beach, in New Hanover County, North Carolina. Its homes were built between 1978 and 2007. A typical home here is about 1,866 square feet with 3 bedrooms.

In the 12 months through November 5, 2026, 1 home sold in Pleasure Cay at a middle price of $1,240,000 (about $590 per square foot). Sellers typically received 100.6% of their first asking price, after about 17 days on the market.

Community features named in Pleasure Cay's listings: Boating access, Water access and Waterfront homes. Check current details and dues with the HOA.

The closest elementary school is Carolina Beach Elementary School (1.5 mi), the nearest grocery store is Publix Super Market Commons at Federal Point (0.6 mi), the nearest public beach access is 0.6 miles away.

Streets in Pleasure Cay

3 streets · A–Z

Tap a street to see its homes. Every address comes from county property records where we have them; homes for sale and sold in the last 12 months come from the MLS.

What's nearby

Schools

Everyday

Outdoors

Health

Distances are straight-line from the middle of Pleasure Cay. Schools shown are the closest, not necessarily assigned — confirm with the district. Place details © Google.

Pleasure Cay questions, answered

How many homes are for sale in Pleasure Cay?

No homes are for sale in Pleasure Cay at the moment. 1 is under contract.

What do homes in Pleasure Cay sell for?

In the 12 months through November 5, 2026 the middle sale price in Pleasure Cay was $1,240,000, about $590 per square foot, across 1 sale. Every home differs — size, condition and lot matter.

How fast do homes sell in Pleasure Cay?

Homes that sold in Pleasure Cay over the last year were typically on the market about 17 days and sold for 100.6% of their first asking price.

What schools are near Pleasure Cay?

Carolina Beach Elementary School (1.5 mi), Charles P. Murray Middle School (3.4 mi), Eugene Ashley High School (3.4 mi). These are the closest schools, not necessarily the assigned ones — confirm assignment with the school district for a specific address.

How far is Pleasure Cay from the beach?

The nearest public beach access, Sand Dollar Public Beach Access, is about 0.6 miles away in a straight line.

What amenities does Pleasure Cay have?

Homes listed for sale in Pleasure Cay describe these community features: Boating access, Water access and Waterfront homes. Amenities, dues and memberships can change — confirm the details with the homeowners association.

Own a home in Pleasure Cay?

Get a home value report built from real sales in Pleasure Cay — not an online guess.

What's my home worth?Text a question

How many listings sold and how many didn't, how long they took, what they sold for against the first price, and how often contracts fell apart — the last 12 months, with a printable PDF.

Carolina Beach market report →Selling a home in Carolina Beach →

From Buddy's blog: Carolina Beach area

More communities in Carolina Beach

Keep looking around Carolina Beach

Community figures are computed from MLS records for homes listed in Pleasure Cay, Carolina Beach.