Sale details
- Sold price
- $255,900
- Sold on
- Mar 30, 2026
- First listed at
- $284,900
- Last asking price
- $269,900 (−5.3%)
- Sold vs. first asking
- 89.8%
- Sold vs. last asking
- 94.8%
- Days on market
- 135
Own a home near 5368 Niagara Carthage Road? See what it would sell for today — from what actually closed around you.
What's my home worth? →About this home
Incredible remodel located minutes from historic downtown Southern Pines and convenient to Fort Bragg! On a big corner lot over half an acre. A home inspection was done on the property with the majority of repairs already completed. These documents were too large to upload in the MLS, so I can email your agent a copy of them. New features include roof, windows, tankless water heater, heat pump, flooring, fixtures, blinds, paint inside and outside, kitchen, almost all of both bathrooms, septic tank, and barn doors! Delight in the kitchen with quartz counters, SS appliances, LVP flooring, subway tile backsplash, a state of the art sink, and a breakfast bar. Built ins in the dining area. Pretty tiled in shower. Patio with fresh landscaping. Storage shed and garden shed in the back and side yards. Addition appears to have been permitted originally, showing both on a 2019 septic tank permit and on tax records. Inside of extra-territorial jurisdiction of Southern Pines. The septic tank is permitted for 2 bedrooms, and an improvement permit from 12.3.25 shows how to upgrade to 3 bedrooms. Your future home awaits you!
Facts
- Type
- Single Family Residence
- Year built
- 1955
- Lot
- 0.61 acres
- County
- Moore
- Stories
- 1
- Construction
- Block, Stucco, Vinyl Siding
- Roof
- Shingle
- Foundation
- Block
- Water
- Well
- Property tax
- $502 / year (2024)
- MLS #
- 100535142
Features
Inside
- Ceiling Fan(s)
- Walk-in Shower
- Blinds/Shades
- LVT/LVP
- Built-In Microwave
- Refrigerator
- Range
- Dishwasher
Outside
- None
Parking
- Gravel
Heating & cooling
- Heat Pump
- Electric
Directions to 5368 Niagara Carthage Road
From downtown Southern Pines: take N. Main St North and take a left on Niagara Carthage. House on the left.
Schools
- Elementary
- McDeeds Creek Elementary
- Middle
- Crain's Creek Middle
- High
- Pinecrest High
As listed in the MLS (Moore County Schools). School assignments can change — confirm with the district for this address.
Explore the area
Popular searches in Southern Pines
- One-story homes in Southern Pines (34)
- Homes with the primary bedroom on the main floor in Southern Pines (92)
- New homes & new construction in Southern Pines (27)
- Homes with a recent price cut in Southern Pines (36)
- Golf community homes in Southern Pines (42)
- Homes in gated communities in Southern Pines (16)
- Homes with no HOA in Southern Pines (61)
- Townhomes in Southern Pines (23)
- Condos in Southern Pines (13)
- Land and lots in Southern Pines (10)
- Luxury homes ($1M+) in Southern Pines (18)
About 5368 Niagara Carthage Road
5368 Niagara Carthage Road is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath home of about 1,304 square feet, built in 1955, on 0.61 acres, Southern Pines, Moore County, NC 28387.
Across ZIP 28387, 42 2-bedroom homes sold in the past year at a median of $337,500.
Area figures are broad context from the MLS, not a valuation — they don't adjust for condition, lot, views or updates. Ask us for a true comparison.
Own a home near 5368 Niagara Carthage Road? See what it's worth — a home value report built from real sales in Southern Pines.
What's my home worth? →Questions about 5368 Niagara Carthage Road
How much is 5368 Niagara Carthage Road?
5368 Niagara Carthage Road sold for $255,900 on March 30, 2026 (last asking price $269,900). It is not for sale now.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 5368 Niagara Carthage Road have?
2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, with about 1,304 square feet.
When was 5368 Niagara Carthage Road built?
1955.
Who is the listing broker for 5368 Niagara Carthage Road?
Century 21 The Realty Group (MLS #100535142).