About this home
The Addison Spencer House is a historic gem located in the heart of Carthage. Built in 1916, the home combines timeless elegance with modern potential. Nestled on over half of an acre, the property boasts stunning architecture that reflects the craftsmanship of its era. As you step inside, you're greeted by the original hardwood floors and soaring high ceilings, which create an inviting atmosphere filled with character. The home currently offers 5 bedrooms and 2 full baths with plenty of space to modify with over 3,700 square feet of living space. The updated kitchen is a stand out feature, complete with a remarkable Butler's pantry and a spacious laundry room offering ample storage. This space not only enhances functionality, but also maintains a connection to the home's historic roots. While the kitchen shines, the rest of the house awaits a visionary touch. Preserving the homes unique charm while updating the bathrooms and other areas will revitalize the property, making it an ideal project for someone who appreciates the beauty of historic homes. Whether you're looking to maintain this property's integrity or put your personal stamp on it, this opportunity is one not to be missed!
Facts
- Type
- Single Family Residence
- Year built
- 1916
- Lot
- 0.56 acres
- Community
- Carthage
- County
- Moore
- Price per sq ft
- $93
- Stories
- 2
- Construction
- Wood Siding, Wood Frame
- Roof
- Composition
- Foundation
- Combination
- Water
- Public
- Property tax
- $2,261 / year (2025)
- Listed
- Jun 30, 2026
- MLS #
- 100553093
Features
Inside
- Master Downstairs
- High Ceilings
- Kitchen Island
- Pantry
- Walk-in Shower
- Wet Bar
- Basement
- Tile
- Wood
- Washer
- Dryer
- Double Oven
- Dishwasher
- Cooktop
Outside
- None
Parking
- No Garage
Heating & cooling
- Electric
- Heat Pump
- Central Air
Directions to 303 Mcreynolds Street
From Carthage Road turn right onto Dowd Road, then left on Saunders Street, then right on S Ray Street and then left onto McReynolds Street and the house will be on your left.
Schools
- Elementary
- Carthage Elementary
- Middle
- New Century Middle
- High
- Union Pines High
As listed in the MLS (Moore County Schools). School assignments can change — confirm with the district for this address.
Payment calculator
Enter the rate a lender quoted you and pick a down payment to see principal and interest for this home. Not sure what to use? See this week's national average at Freddie Mac ↗
Get your actual rate for this home — usually same day
Joey Milam, Alpha Mortgage Advantage · NMLS #117399 · You're free to choose any lender.
Recent sales like this nearby
| Home | Sold | Bd / Ba | Sq ft | Price | $ / sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 701 Sunset Drive, Carthage | Sep 30, 2026 | 3 / 3 | 2,835 | $494,997 | $175 |
| 912 Sunset Drive, Carthage | Jul 20, 2026 | 5 / 4 | 2,939 | $515,000 | $175 |
| 801 Monroe Street, Carthage | Sep 11, 2026 | 5 / 2 | 3,191 | $340,000 | $107 |
Similar size and type, sold in the last 6 months. From Hive MLS records; deemed reliable, not guaranteed.
Buying in Carthage? Local guides
- Before You List on the NC Coast: Inspect, Repair or Sell As-Is?What to do before listing a home in Wilmington and the southeastern NC coast: a pre-market inspection, what to fix, credit or disclose, roof/HVAC/insurance questions coastal buyers ask, photos, pricing and offers.
- How Much Are Property Taxes in Wilmington and the NC Coast? (2026-27)County and town property tax rates for New Hanover, Brunswick, Pender, Onslow and Duplin, what they cost on a $400,000 home, the 2027 revaluations to plan for, and tax relief you may qualify for.
- One-Story and Primary-on-Main Homes on the Southeastern NC CoastWhere the one-level homes are from Wilmington to Calabash, what they cost town by town, and what to check before you buy — from current MLS listings.
Explore the area
Popular searches in Carthage
About 303 Mcreynolds Street
303 Mcreynolds Street is a 5-bedroom, 2-bath home of about 3,745 square feet, built in 1916, on 0.56 acres in Carthage, Carthage, Moore County, NC 28327.
2 other homes are for sale in Carthage right now (median asking $424,500); 6 homes sold there in the last 12 months at a median of $321,000, typically in about 87 days.
Across ZIP 28327, 39 5-bedroom homes sold in the past year at a median of $550,000.
Area figures are broad context from the MLS, not a valuation — they don't adjust for condition, lot, views or updates. Ask us for a true comparison.
Carthage neighborhood guideHomes for sale in CarthageMoore County homes
Buying 303 Mcreynolds Street
- See it in person. Pick a time and we'll call to confirm — often same day.
- Practice your offer. Try our new Offer Simulator: see how a seller might answer, go back and forth, and learn how offers work in NC. No risk, no sign-up.
- Have a home to sell first? Our guaranteed sale lets you buy with a firm plan for your current home. How it works
Own a home near 303 Mcreynolds Street? See what it's worth — a home value report built from real sales in Carthage.
What's my home worth? →Questions about 303 Mcreynolds Street
How much is 303 Mcreynolds Street?
303 Mcreynolds Street is under contract. Its last asking price was $349,000.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 303 Mcreynolds Street have?
5 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, with about 3,745 square feet.
What neighborhood is 303 Mcreynolds Street in?
Carthage, in Carthage, Moore County, North Carolina.
What have homes sold for in Carthage?
6 homes sold in Carthage in the last 12 months, at a median price of $321,000.
When was 303 Mcreynolds Street built?
1916.
Who is the listing broker for 303 Mcreynolds Street?
Keller Williams Pinehurst (MLS #100553093).
Can I tour 303 Mcreynolds Street?
Yes. Tap “Schedule a tour,” pick a time, and we'll call to confirm — or call or text (910) 395-1000.